All thoughts

Thoughts · Essay

What the Driving Test Doesn’t Teach You

A teenager passes their driving test. They come home, put the certificate on the kitchen table and ask for the car keys. They’re delighted, and you’re delighted for them. Then they leave, and you find yourself listening for the sound of the car coming back.

They know the rules. They’ve proved they can use them with someone sitting beside them. What they haven’t had yet is the experience of coming down a familiar street and seeing a football roll out from between two parked cars. An experienced driver is already easing off before the child appears. If you asked them afterwards what they did, they might say, “I slowed down.” The useful part is when they slowed down, and what they saw that made them do it.

I think about that when someone tells me how a business works. You can read the process, watch the slides and still miss the moment a good employee decides to do something different. Ask them how they do their job and they’ll often give you the tidy version themselves. Sit beside them on a busy afternoon and you’ll hear them say, “Hang on, I want to check something.” Most of what I’d want to learn is in the next five minutes.

Say the system shows a shipment is ready. The person who’s been running dispatch for years calls the warehouse anyway. There was a late change to the order, and she knows the screen can show the original paperwork as complete before the revised loading list comes through. Ask her how dispatch works on a quiet Tuesday and that detail might never come up. Ask her about the last truck she held back and she can tell you what she noticed, whom she called and what would have made her let it go.

Sometimes there’s a good reason for the detour. Sometimes it’s an old workaround everyone kept doing long after the problem went away. I’d want to know which before teaching it to anyone, especially to software that can repeat it a thousand times without asking why.

It works much the same way outside a business. You can ask someone for a recipe they’ve made for forty years and follow it to the letter. Spend an afternoon in the kitchen with them and they’ll tell you to leave the dough a little longer because the room is cold. They never thought to write that down. Chances are they’d forgotten it was something they once had to learn.

What worries me is how much of that judgment we could lose in the next few years. The people who know why things are done a certain way are still here. Some are near retirement; others will simply move on. Once they leave, we may still have the handbook, the system logs and a perfectly respectable account of how the place operated. The log might even show that the truck left forty minutes late. It won’t tell you why someone was right to hold it. The person who can explain that decision is the missing link. Once the last person who knows is gone, the tidy version becomes the only one anyone has left to learn from.

I think it’s worth spending a surprising amount of time on this. If someone is leaving in six months, give them part of their working week now to work alongside the people who’ll carry the job forward. Take some of the day job off their plate so they can do it properly. Let the other person take the lead and ask questions as things happen. Bring back the cases that made experienced people disagree. An hour at an exit interview will get you the names of the files. A few months together gives you a chance to understand why some of those files could safely be ignored, and why others couldn’t.

There’s something in this about what we value in people. We’re quick to ask what someone delivered and much less curious about what they noticed, what they quietly prevented or what they knew enough to leave alone. A lot of their best work never became an event anyone had to report. If you want to pass that on, you have to give people a chance to show it in the course of doing the work. I wouldn’t leave that to their last week.

Cookie settings

Optional analytics measures visits, reading progress and link clicks. Rejecting it leaves the website fully available. Read the privacy & cookies notice.